Good Girls Don’t Do Anal

SCENE OPENS as Rick, a college student, is watching TV one afternoon at his girlfriend parents’ house. Gina, who recently turned 18, is housesitting for her folks and casually enters the room with a snack for her boyfriend. She is madly in love with him … and her parents approve too. Even though they are a few years apart, Rick has always been accepted as part of the family. Now, with them away for the whole week, it’s the perfect opportunity for the couple to play house and Gina is soaking up every minute of it. She sits beside her man, snuggles up, and watches while he eats. After a few minutes of small talk, a look comes over Rick. ‘Hey, do you want to do something else?’ He asks coyly. Before Gina can respond, he pulls her onto her lap and starts to kiss her. She smiles and kisses him back, unbuttoning his shirt. The young couple tear each other’s clothes off as they make out. After a few intense minutes of foreplay, Rick flips Gina onto all fours to mount her. The camera focuses on her reaction, as she eagerly waits for her boyfriend to enter. He kisses down her back and leans back to penetrate, when suddenly, her expression changes. ‘WAIT!’ She yells, and Rick pulls out and sits back. ‘What?’ he asks, a sly smirk on his face. Looking irritated, she stands up and starts gathering her things in silence. ‘What?!’ he asks again. ‘Like I told you last time, Rick!’ she says sternly. ‘You keep trying to put it in the wrong hole!’

CUT TO TITLE PLATE

The next morning. Gina steps out of the shower, wrapping a towel around her body. She goes to the vanity and starts brushing her teeth when she begins to hear sounds coming from her room. She left her boyfriend sleeping in there. Spitting out her toothpaste, she struts back into her room to find her boyfriend watching porn on her laptop. ‘Rick!’ she interrupts. ‘What are you doing? It’s 10am!’ He acts aloof and she walks over to the screen, peering down to see what it is he’s watching. It’s an anal sex scene. ‘That’s disgusting!’ she says. Rick slowly pulls off her towel, cooing ‘This is what I always do in the morning, babe. I thought you wanted to play house this week? I’m just trying to keep it real!’ He charms her onto the bed and, trying to hide her smile, she sits down. ‘I don’t know why you need to watch that stuff when you have me right here,’ she says quietly. Rick looks her right in the eye. ‘Because I’m a dude and that’s what we do.’ Awkwardly, she kisses him and asks that he not watch it at her house. Leaning in close, he whispers that he wouldn’t have to if she just let him try it once. The camera lingers on Gina’s conflicted face.

One day later. Gina is cooking in the kitchen when Rick comes home from class. He drops his backpack and jokingly says ‘honey, I’m home!’ before running in to kiss her. She seems very happy to be playing house and asks him to help her finish dinner. While they cook together, she asks about his day and reiterates how fun it’s been this week to live together. Now that she is 18, they should start to talk about doing it for real. Rick appeases her, agreeing to everything, as his hands start to run down her waist and around her ass. The more she talks, the more distracted he gets, kissing her neck and start to rub himself up against her backside. At first, she finds it cute but soon gets frustrated at how focused her boyfriend is on her butt. She stops him and demands respect. How many times does she have to tell him: good girls don’t have anal sex. This time, Rick reacts differently. Rather than brush it off or make light of it, he looks genuinely angry. Blowing up at her, he tells her that he doesn’t understand why she’s such a prude. They’ve been together for three years. He has always been a gentleman. All his friend’s girlfriends give it up no problem. Why is she holding him back from trying something he’s always wanted to try? Does she want to push him away? There are plenty of girls at his school who’d been willing to help him out! Gina is dumbstruck by her boyfriend’s reaction. She asks him if that’s an ultimatum and, shaking his head, he tells her that he can’t do it any longer. He’s breaking up with her. He storms out of the house, grabbing his bag on the way out, and leaves the girl to crumble into tears in the kitchen.

One day later. Gina sits, heartbroken, on her bed. She opens her laptop and finds the last page viewed on her browser: the anal sex scene her boyfriend had been watching. She stares at it coldly, pressing play and watching in silence as her room fills with sounds of anal orgasms.

Two days later. Gina opens the door to let Rick inside. It’s been three days since he stormed out of her parent’s house and she is beside herself. She has texted him and asked to talk to him. Taking his hand, she leads him back to her bedroom and sits him down on the bed. He isn’t sure how to react.

She takes a long deep breath before breaking into a speech, something she clearly spent the last few days preparing. She tells him that she loves him, that he is her best friend, and that she wants to spend the rest of her life with him. She knows how much he wants to try anal and, after thinking it over, she will agree to try it for him. But only once and ONLY if he promises to leave it alone afterwards. Rick’s face lights up. He asks if she is sure. Looking at him coldly, she tells him yes. She’ll do it … for him. This descends into the BGA scene. It takes a long time to get the first successful anal penetration and Gina resigns herself to the ‘painal’ feelings that come with having anal sex for the first time. Rick eagerly talks her through it, every step of the way, taking great pleasure in the experience. The more she loosens up, the more he enjoys it. Overall, the sex scene should accurately portray a first-time anal experience with hyper-realism in terms of reactions.

After he has pulled out and cum on her ass, Rick happily curls up beside his girlfriend in bed. He kisses her and tells her how much he loves her. He thanks her profusely for letting them try this together. Overwhelmed by the experience but happy her boyfriend is back, Gina grimaces and tells him she loves him too. As they fall asleep, Rick whispers softly in her ear that, next time, they should try it with one of his friends. Her eyes pop open, as she realizes what she’s gotten herself into!