Katie (Gabbie Carter) is curled up miserably on her bed, surrounded by crumpled tissues and food wrappers. She’s been too depressed to go to school for the past few days, but today she has no choice but to go back. She opens her closet door to get her school uniform, but gets upset when she sees her cheerleader outfit, hinting that her depression has something to do with cheerleading.
Later that day, after school, Katie spots her schoolmate Maria (Jane Wilde), who is wearing a cheerleading uniform. Katie’s eyes narrow with contempt, and she decides to follow Maria to her home. When Maria arrives at her house, she is surprised to see that Katie has followed her, but she gloatingly calls Katie ‘ex-captain’, and arrogantly invites her inside.
From their conversation, it is revealed that Katie used to be the captain of the cheerleading squad, but she got kicked off the squad after she was somehow outed as a lesbian. The school’s conservative faculty didn’t want a lesbian on the squad, and someone spread a false rumor that Katie was looking up the other cheerleaders’ skirts, so nobody on the squad wanted to defend her. Katie accuses Maria, the new cheerleading captain, of being the one who outed her and spread the terrible rumor. Not only that, but Katie is sure that the only way Maria could have known that she’s a lesbian is if Maria is also a lesbian herself.
Maria isn’t shy about admitting that she is the one who outed Katie, and taunts that Katie has no hope of getting back on the squad. To Maria’s surprise, Katie says that she has no desire to rejoin the squad. Katie says that what she really wants is for Maria to admit to her that she’s a lesbian, too. She just wants the personal satisfaction of knowing that Maria is a hypocrite.
Maria decides that she’s already won, so she admits to Katie that she is a lesbian too. But to her shock, Katie begins to gloat, saying that Maria will have to keep that a secret for YEARS, if she doesn’t want to get kicked out of the squad like Katie was. That means Maria won’t be able to date or have sex. Meanwhile, Katie is free to be herself, since everyone now knows that she’s a lesbian. That’s why Katie doesn’t need revenge… because the best revenge is knowing that Maria screwed HERSELF. Maria briefly looks stricken, as she realizes that what Katie said is true. Katie gleefully offers Maria a pity fuck, which she accepts. After all, it’s the last time Maria will be able to have sex for quite a while…